Agenda item

MEMBERS' USE OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY

·          Notes from the meetings of the working group on 22nd September 2005 and 20th October 2005.

·          Notes from the meeting on 8th November 2005 and a report from the working group on members training and broadband for members will be circulated at the meeting.

(Enclosures)

Minutes:

Members had before them notes from the meetings of the Members’ IT Working Group on 22nd September and 20th October 2005. Notes from the meeting held on 8th November 2005 were circulated at the meeting. Councillor Nadarajah, the lead member of the working group, highlighted the recommendations contained within the notes, which were discussed by the panel.

 

The new system being rolled out on members’ laptops was highly praised as a simple interface for members. Councillor Nadarajah commented on the high standard of the IT helpdesk but members considered that there should be an evening provision, to which Councillor Nadarajah stated that he would look into this. The recommendation concerning training prompted some discussion on what members thought would be the best training solution. It was agreed that those in the recommendation were sufficient. It was suggested that members should only be sent the frontsheet but this was not possible as members were allowed to request full paper copies. The recommendation concerning broadband was also supported as this would provide a comprehensive desktop support for members, facilitate a better service for constituents through their ward member, reduce printing costs for agendas and assist in the expediting of information.

 

Conclusions:

 

(1)   That the following be recommended to the Access and Engagement Portfolio Holder:

 

(a)   To support the implementation of the new menu style interface for members’ laptops;

(b)  To recognise that individual councillors have their own problems with using their laptops and therefore need addressing individually;

(c)   To encourage members to write out or print error messages to assist in the communication to ICT of problems with laptops;

(d)  To approve that members of the Members’ IT Working Group contact those members who did not respond to the 2005 Laptop Survey and approach them individually by setting up a meeting with the members and an appointed mentor from the working group.

(e)   That training for members on the use of ICT be provided through a structured portfolio of training options to cater for the variety of training needs. This to include:

§         One on one training

§         Small groups

§         Self study CDROMS with video demonstrations

§         IT Buddies (with support)

§         Supported learning playdays

§         An integrated learning approach to training e.g. ‘laptop month’

[Priority be given to those members with most difficulties in using their laptop and new users. Level of previous training will not affect the prioritisation of future training.

 

Training to be provided, where possible and suitable, on days when committee meetings are scheduled to enable members to attend both in one visit to the council offices].

 

(2)   That the following response be made to Cabinet on its Broadband for Members proposals:

 

Cabinet Proposal

Scrutiny Response

 

1. The Cabinet supports in principle the introduction of Broadband to all Members in order to improve the utilisation and effectiveness of their home working arrangements;

Supported

2. A strategy be developed to eliminate the existing duplication of costs in printing and postage of reports as members adopt new working practices;

Supported

3. Funding to be provided for a start up programme of Broadband connectivity.  These costs will reduce over time but, initially, estimates indicate between £15,000 and £25,000 in year one, reducing to an ongoing annual cost, in the future, of around £10,000, depending on negotiations with suppliers;

Supported – The Members’ IT Working Group to scrutinise procurement for broadband, recommend a specification and invite the Procurement Officer and Portfolio Holder to assist.

4. Plans to deliver the equivalent savings of approximately £10,000 per annum be drawn up to fund the additional investment;

Supported – It is suggested that cost savings would be established from less printing. The Members’ IT Working Group to scrutinise this with assistance from Accountancy and the Corporate Director

 

Alternative Option

Scrutiny Response

 

A – Improve the e-mail delivery access problems by ensuring file sizes being delivered are below a certain size.  This should already be in place but restricts functionality.

Not supported - this would be very restrictive. It is difficult to know where to pitch the restriction level. It is dependent on too many different factors. It would be very difficult to implement.

B –  Produce CD Roms with the Members mail and documents.  These would be posted to the Member’s address.This option could be utilised for those not on Broadband links.

Not supported – a CD Rom would only be as good as the time it is burnt. Additional information that would be instantaneously published on modern.gov would not be up to date on the CD Rom thereby limiting communication. CD Roms would duplicate work already done on producing committee papers on modern.gov. CD Roms would take the focus completely way from what we are trying to achieve in encouraging the comprehensive use of electronic communications, which is evolving at the present time.

 

CD Roms for those members who cannot receive broadband, may be a suitable alternative to paper agendas.

C – Let Members introduce Broadband as they see fit with an allowance being paid as they adopt its use.  The Council would negotiate with and recommend a supplier.

Not supported - it will be cumbersome to monitor and to negotiate individual broadband deals. A cheaper deal can be achieved via one negotiation with suppliers. Members’ IT should be uniform, consistent and seamless to improve usability for members as well as supporting staff.

D – Introduce more docking stations at Council Offices e.g. Stamford, Bourne and the Deepings for quick updates on files.

Supported – This could be an enhancement to the introduction of broadband, especially for those members who are unable to receive broadband at home.

Supporting documents: